★ Demo Swaps ★ the rules ★ you play theirs ★ they play yours ★ round 2 sign-ups open ★ Demo Swaps ★ the rules ★ you play theirs ★ they play yours ★ round 2 sign-ups open ★
Demo Swaps is a free, dev-to-dev feedback exchange for indie game demos.
There are more demos out there than anyone can play, and good games get buried. Demo Swaps fixes a small piece of that: you play 5 demos from other devs, and about 5 devs play yours. Everyone gets honest, written feedback, and the best-rated demos of each round are featured in a public selection for players.
#2How a round works
Step
How long
What happens
1. Sign up
about 1 week
Submit one playable demo (Steam or itch.io) and, if you like, one question for your reviewers
2. Assignment
1 day
You receive your demos by email, assigned at random
3. Play & review
7 days
Play each demo and fill in the review form
4. Results
2 days
You get your feedback; the round's selection goes public
How many demos you play depends on the size of the round:
11 devs or more: you review 5 demos and get about 5 reviews.
7 to 10 devs: you review 3 demos and get 3 reviews.
Fewer than 7: sign-ups stay open a few days longer.
Rounds run every two weeks. Dates are announced on the Discord and on this site.
#3Who can join
Indie developers with a free, playable demo on Steam or itch.io.
One demo per developer (or team) per round.
Demo not public yet? That's fine if you give reviewers access (Steam keys, or an itch.io password or download keys). A private demo can't be featured in the public selection until it's public.
The demo must run on Windows, or in the browser. itch.io web builds are welcome: they are the quickest to try.
No adult/NSFW content.
We check every submission by hand. Fake accounts, store pages with no real demo, or mass-produced listings will be removed.
#4The rules
Review every demo assigned to you (5, or 3 in a small round).
Your feedback unlocks only after you complete your reviews. No reviews, no feedback.
If you don't finish your reviews, you won't receive your feedback and your demo won't be eligible for the public selection that round.
Play for real. Play each demo for at least 15 minutes, or to the end if it's shorter.
Be honest and kind. Criticize the game, not the person. Insults, harassment, or bad-faith reviews get you removed.
No trading reviews. Don't coordinate scores with other participants, and don't contact the devs you're reviewing (or your reviewers) while the round is running. After results are out, scores are final, and devs can reach the reviewers who agreed to follow-up questions.
Keep it private. The feedback you receive is yours to use, but don't publish other devs' reviews of their games without their permission.
#5How assignment works
Demos are assigned at random, and each demo gets different reviewers.
No mutual pairs: if you review someone's demo, they won't review yours in the same round.
We avoid giving you the same demo twice across rounds. The one exception is a second look: if your demo changed since last round and your question asks whether something improved, someone who played the earlier version may review it again. It's an extra review on top of your usual ones, and it's marked as a second look.
At sign-up you can exclude up to 2 genres you never play (e.g. horror, visual novels), so you don't judge a game by a genre you dislike.
At sign-up you can also choose to get only Steam and browser demos, if you'd rather not download and run files from itch.io.
#6The review form
Short on purpose, because you'll fill it in several times:
Time played: under 10 min / 10–30 min / finished the demo / couldn't get it to run
First two minutes: is the core idea clear? (1–5)
Game feel: controls, responsiveness, feedback (1–5)
Polish and consistency: visuals, audio, UI (1–5)
Originality: is there something you haven't seen a hundred times? (1–5)
Would you wishlist it? yes / maybe / no
Where did you want to quit? the moment you felt like stopping, if there was one (one line)
One thing that works (at least 2 sentences)
One thing to improve (at least 2 sentences)
The developer's question: your answer to the question the dev asked, if they asked one
Follow-up: can the developer contact you on Discord with questions after results? yes / no
We judge the result, not the tools. There is no question about how the game was made.
#7Ask your reviewers one question
The form covers what every demo needs. If there's something specific you're unsure about, you can ask your reviewers directly.
At sign-up, write one question (max 200 characters) that someone can answer after 15 minutes with your demo. For example: "Was the tutorial clear?", "Did the first boss feel unfair?", "Did you understand what the blue crystals do?"
Your reviewers see it in their form, after they've given their scores, so it doesn't influence the ratings.
It's optional. Leave it empty and you'll get the standard review.
#8Follow-up questions
Sometimes a review raises a new question ("what do you mean, the controls feel weird?"). At the end of each review, reviewers choose whether the dev may contact them after results. If they say yes, their Discord username is sent to you together with their review. Reviewers who say no stay anonymous.
#9If a demo won't run
Give it up to 15 minutes, then choose "couldn't get it to run" in the form and describe what happened (your OS, the error, where it got stuck). It counts as one of your reviews, and the developer gets your report: a bug report is useful feedback too.
#10Review quality
When you get your feedback, you can mark each review as helpful / not helpful. This doesn't change any score; it builds the reviewer's reputation.
Reviewers who repeatedly leave empty, copy-pasted, or unhelpful reviews will not be invited to the next round.
Outlier scores (for example, one 1 when every other reviewer gave 4–5) may be excluded from the averages.
#11What you get
Privately:
Your written reviews.
Their answers to your question, if you asked one.
Your average scores, compared with the round average.
The Discord usernames of reviewers who agreed to follow-up questions.
Publicly (if you're selected):
A spot in the Round Selection: roughly the top 10% of demos, shared on Reddit, Discord and this site, with direct links to your demo.
To be eligible for the selection, a demo needs:
at least 3 completed reviews;
the highest share of "yes, I'd wishlist it";
a developer who completed all of their own reviews.
#12The organizer's games
The organizer is an indie dev too. If the organizer's own game takes part in a round, it gets reviewed like everyone else's, but it is never included in the public selection.
#13Your data
We collect your name or studio name, email, Discord username, and your demo's link. They are used only to run Demo Swaps: sending assignments and feedback, and publishing the selection. Your Discord username is shared with a dev you reviewed only if you said yes to follow-up questions in that review. Otherwise we don't sell or share your data. Ask on Discord or write to matteo.games2@gmail.com to have your data deleted.
This site counts visits with Umami, which uses no cookies and collects no personal data.
#14Changes
The rules will change based on what we learn, and every change is announced before the round it applies to. Feedback on the rules themselves is very welcome.
New in Round 1 (after the Round 0 pilot):
The project is now called Demo Swaps, and the rules live on this site.
Sign-ups stay open about a week instead of three days.
Round size: small rounds (7–10 devs) use 3 reviews each instead of 5.
At sign-up you say how your demo is played (Steam, browser or download), and you can choose to get only Steam and browser demos.
Selection: at least 3 completed reviews instead of 4, to fit small rounds.
New question in the review form: "Where did you want to quit?" When several reviewers name the same spot, that's the first thing to fix.
Returning demos can get a second look from someone who played the earlier version, as an extra review.
Demos that aren't public yet are welcome, as long as reviewers get access (Steam keys or an itch.io password).